top of page

Carbon Footprint Showdown: How to Keep Warm Sustainably (Without Heating the Planet)

TL;DR: Staying warm in the winter doesn't have to cost you or the planet all that much. Discover whether a heated blanket or a radiator is the more eco-friendly choice—and learn how to stay cozy while reducing your carbon footprint.

 

As Jack Frost paints intricate patterns on your windows and your breath hangs visible in the air, the annual battle against winter's chill begins anew.

Person in winter clothing blows snow from hands, creating a sparkling effect. Background is snowy and bright, evoking a serene mood to answer the question: which is the more sustainable heating option?
Winter is here: Time to Bundle Up

Across the Northern Hemisphere, millions are seeking refuge from the biting cold, each with their own strategy for creating a cozy haven. But in our increasingly climate-conscious world, the quest for warmth has taken on a new dimension: How can we stay toasty without toasting the planet?


It's a startling fact: space heating gobbles up over 60% of energy use in European households. As temperatures drop, our carbon footprints tend to rise. Whether you're weathering a polar vortex or just trying to make movie night more snuggly, your choice of heating technology can have a significant impact on both your comfort and the environment.


A Tale of Two Warmers

Which is the best sustainable heating option? Radiator on left vs blue electric blanket with a control on right, separated by a "VS" graphic with lightning bolt. Cozy, comparative mood.
The Contenders: Radiators vs. Heated Blankets

In this winter-inspired carbon footprint showdown, we're pitting two popular heating options against each other: the classic radiator and the modern electric blanket. Which will emerge as the champion of eco-friendly coziness? Good luck to our competitors- may the best warmer win!


Radiators: The Old Guard of Home Heating


White radiator shaped like a house against a teal wall. The floor is light-colored. Minimalistic and cozy ambiance to answer the question: which is the more sustainable heating option?
Radiating Warmth... but What Else?

First up, we have the radiator, a champion at keeping homes warm since the Victorian era. And they're not going out of style anytime soon-- the European radiator market is heating up, valued at a whopping US$2.93 billion in 2024 and is expected to reach US$5.58 billion by 2032! 


But this old-school warmth comes at a cost. We did the math, and it turns out that running a radiator for a 10-hour night produces about 3.37 kg of CO₂e—equivalent to a 15 km car journey. Plus, natural gas-powered radiators can emit volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and particulate matter, potentially compromising your indoor air quality.


Heated Blankets: The Cozy (and Sustainable) Revolution


A folded white heated blanket with a remote lies on a gray bedspread featuring triangle patterns, creating a cozy atmosphere. Is this the more sustainable heating option?
Electric blankets have got you covered.

Enter our next contender— the electric blanket. This affordable snuggly alternative is a more modern approach to personal warmth, with a market share that's not to be yawned at: the global market currently hovers around US$1.2 Billion and is expected to reach US$2.3 Billion within 10 years. The largest market for electric blankets is in Europe, offering dependable and effective heat and comfort during the harsh winter weather.


The environmental impact? It's night and day. A typical queen-sized heated blanket can use 100 to 200 watts per hour, depending on the setting. This translates to a mere 0.39 kg of CO₂e for an overnight use—an 88% reduction compared to radiators. As a bonus, using heated blankets in lieu of radiators can reduce harmful pollutants: volatile organic compounds decrease by 67% and particulate matter by 14%, contributing to cleaner air and potentially better sleep.

With Great Power Comes Great Emissions: The Green Grid Factor


You may be thinking, "An electric blanket consumes energy, so how can its emissions be so low compared to a radiator?" Great question. The answer lies not just in the blanket's efficiency, but in the evolving nature of our power grids. As electricity networks increasingly rely on renewable sources like wind, solar, and hydropower, the carbon footprint of electric devices is shrinking.

Solar panels in the foreground with power lines in the background at sunset, creating a serene and industrial mood for a network electric grid for sustainable heating. Bright, clear sky.
More Renewables, Less Emissions

The starting carbon value for electric blankets is already low compared to natural gas-powered radiators, and it's set to drop even further. In many regions, the grid is becoming greener by the day. For instance, in 2023 renewable energy sources accounted for about 24% of electricity generation in the EU, up from 20% in 2020. This trend means that every year, your heated blanket's carbon footprint gets a little smaller without you having to do anything.


Contrast this with gas radiators, which have a fixed carbon output regardless of grid improvements. As we transition to a more sustainable energy future, electric heating options like blankets are positioned to become even more environmentally friendly, making them a smart choice for the climate-conscious consumer.


About This Carbon Comparison: Doing the Math


This simulation is inspired by the C-mulator™, an innovative carbon footprint simulation tool by ECO-OS that empowers marketing and sales teams to demonstrate the impact of the advanced, sustainability-optimized material choices - in real-time.

A computer with a screen showing the C-mulator, an innovative carbon footprint simulation tool that empowers marketing and sales teams to demonstrate the impact of the advanced, sustainable and ESG optimized material choices they are offering.
The C-mulator Demonstrates the Carbon Advantage of Your Materials vs. The Competition

Methodology and Results


For this winter warming showdown, we assumed:


  1. Heated blanket: 2.48 kg, made in China, used 100 days/year for 7.5 years

  2. Radiator: 42.17 kg (including boiler), made in Poland, used 100 days/year for 15 years

  3. Usage: 10-hour night, queen-sized blanket vs. average European bedroom

  4. Power sources: Regional electric grid (blanket) vs. natural gas (radiator)

  5. Emission factors sourced from UK Dept. for Energy Security & Net Zero, IPCC, and ADEME France.

  6. Air pollution data from PRTR energy calculators.


Here's how the results stacked up:


Horizontal bar graphs showing the results of the sustainable heating winter carbon footprint showdown: Radiator at 3.37 kg co2e for a single use and heated blanket at 0.39 kg co2e.
The Heated Blanket's Low Carbon Footprint is Nothing to Yawn At

We hereby declare the Heated Blanket as the official winner of this winter carbon footprint showdown!

 

Ready to empower your company to lead in transparent and impactful sustainability solutions?


Book a demo of the C-mulator™ to learn more!

 

Bundling Up the Carbon Footprint Showdown: Some Comforting Results for Sustainable Heating


Blue-lit bedroom with rumpled bed, soft pillows, a table lamp, blinds in the background, and an electric blanket controller visible, your number one sustainable heating option.
Your Winter Winner: The Heated Blanket

When it comes to carbon-conscious warmth, the heated blanket emerges as the clear winter winner. It dramatically cuts emissions, saves on energy and installation costs and even improves air quality. But the best solution might be a combination of approaches—using a heated blanket for personal warmth while maintaining a lower ambient temperature in your home. Remember, every degree matters—both on your thermostat and for our planet.


While individuals can make small changes to reduce their winter carbon footprints, businesses have an opportunity to take these principles further. By adopting ESG-focused tools like the C-mulatorâ„¢, organizations can champion sustainability and inspire others to prioritize eco-friendly solutions.


By making informed choices about how we heat our spaces, we can all contribute to a more sustainable, and still comfortably warm, future. What's your go-to method for staying warm in winter? Share your eco-friendly heating hacks with us on social media by tagging #Cmulatorsimulations and #Sustainablematerialswaps and join the conversation about sustainable comfort!


Stay cozy—and climate-conscious!

 

Follow us and stay tuned for the next edition of our new series: Carbon Footprint This or That



bottom of page